Smasher talk:Egghead

For the doubt for lack of notability. Actually Egghead is pretty well-known and popular in Hong Kong smash community. Some people even asked me why he doesn't have a wiki page before I create this page. Xoei (talk) 20:42, November 13, 2023 (EST)

"Well known and popular" is still different than notability, at least notability in terms of how the wiki defines it. In other words, there can be a person who is well-liked in the community but don't have any good results to show. Looking at Egghead on SmashData, he has a 19.15% set win count and 26.85% game win count, which is far below our standards for notability.

That being said, if you can show that Egghead has made an impact on the tournament scene, whether it's TOing or commentating, and not because he is a well-liked or popular guy, then I can see this page staying. CookiesCreme 21:18, November 13, 2023 (EST)

Thanks for your explan. Sorry for my misunderstand about notability in smash. I can understand and receive the delete now. Xoei (talk) 03:39, November 14, 2023 (EST)

Support. Not much else to add as the reasons are already very clear. NPM Morr!? 05:56, November 23, 2023 (EST)

I may actually be a touch against on this one - since its creation there's a few more decent placements, inc 33rd at a 100+ attendance tournament here. Not entirely sure about who's good/bad in Hong Kong though, would have to have a look. - Plague von Karma 19:48, August 13, 2024 (EDT)