Talk:Princess Peach (SSBM): Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 10: | Line 10: | ||
Just a note, the part that says "Yuna's guide to edgeguarding" should probably be changed. For starters, many of the strategies are implemented by...well every peach player. But mainly, this is a wiki, which means no credit is given things such as guides (although it can be used a referance), and once any of those strategies are changed its no longer Yuna's guide. This of course is the problem with wiki's, in that anyone can edit and that no credit is given, but its more for a public service than credit.[[User:Alphazealot|Alphazealot]] 07:09, February 25, 2007 (GMT) | Just a note, the part that says "Yuna's guide to edgeguarding" should probably be changed. For starters, many of the strategies are implemented by...well every peach player. But mainly, this is a wiki, which means no credit is given things such as guides (although it can be used a referance), and once any of those strategies are changed its no longer Yuna's guide. This of course is the problem with wiki's, in that anyone can edit and that no credit is given, but its more for a public service than credit.[[User:Alphazealot|Alphazealot]] 07:09, February 25, 2007 (GMT) | ||
I'd like to second Alphazealot's comment -- In addition to Yuna's guide to edgeguarding, all of the homerun contest entries are attributed to a single person, which from what i understand isn't the point of the wiki. If you are citing material from some form of copyrighted material with permission, then by all means cite it, but if everyone adds little pieces to the wiki and then puts their name after them, it'll start looking really messy really fast. I'm not comfortable flat out removing the credits myself, but i'd like to see some justification for why they should be there. | I'd like to second Alphazealot's comment -- In addition to Yuna's guide to edgeguarding, all of the homerun contest entries are attributed to a single person, which from what i understand isn't the point of the wiki. If you are citing material from some form of copyrighted material with permission, then by all means cite it, but if everyone adds little pieces to the wiki and then puts their name after them, it'll start looking really messy really fast. I'm not comfortable flat out removing the credits myself, but i'd like to see some justification for why they should be there. ---- | ||
Revision as of 12:49, March 15, 2007
My god.. very well done, XiF. o_o-b
*slaps award sticker on article* --Manta
Woah, What's this all about? "(though she appeared as a fighter in Super Mario RPG, though that game was never released outside of Japan)" Super Mario RPG never leaving Japan? Thats Legend of the Seven Stars right? That had to have left Japan! I have a copy it, in English, of course.
This article is EXTREMELY well done. It would be wonderful if all character pages were as complete as this. Now we know what to shoot for! Who did this? Whoever you are you deserve a lot of credit. -- Bean 02:46, November 1, 2006 (GMT)
Just a note, the part that says "Yuna's guide to edgeguarding" should probably be changed. For starters, many of the strategies are implemented by...well every peach player. But mainly, this is a wiki, which means no credit is given things such as guides (although it can be used a referance), and once any of those strategies are changed its no longer Yuna's guide. This of course is the problem with wiki's, in that anyone can edit and that no credit is given, but its more for a public service than credit.Alphazealot 07:09, February 25, 2007 (GMT)
I'd like to second Alphazealot's comment -- In addition to Yuna's guide to edgeguarding, all of the homerun contest entries are attributed to a single person, which from what i understand isn't the point of the wiki. If you are citing material from some form of copyrighted material with permission, then by all means cite it, but if everyone adds little pieces to the wiki and then puts their name after them, it'll start looking really messy really fast. I'm not comfortable flat out removing the credits myself, but i'd like to see some justification for why they should be there. ----
