User talk:Toomai/Why SSB4 should be good

I'd like to point out the subjective nature of what is considered "best" from each game. For example many casual and brawl players take issue with the many movement options in Melee such as wavedashing and dash dancing, when in fact they've done nothing but add depth and actually meld quite well with many character as well as the basic game engine in general. For all we know Smash 4 could be a combination of what Melee players consider unimportant in Melee and things that we hated in Brawl (like it's lack of the aforementioned movement options).--Brian^{Don't try me!} 05:16, 30 April 2014 (EDT)

"Blah blah blah. Negative negative negative." —|3rian.

C'mon dude, can't you at least try to be a little bit positive about this game? It seems that for the first time, Sakurai and Nintendo are giving the competitive community consideration and are trying to include them as a factor in their decision-making for the new game. They clearly learned from their mistake in Brawl, that ignoring the competitive community and focusing completely on casual players alienates people, and they're moving to fix that mistake this time. It's not very often that a gaming company, let alone Nintendo, does this. I think that should at least count for something. DoctorPain99 10:36, 30 April 2014 (EDT)

Also, @Toomai, I'd say Castlevania 1, 2, and 3 follow this pattern as well, if you're looking for more examples. DoctorPain99 10:39, 30 April 2014 (EDT)

You didn't even address any single one of my points. What you said proves nothing.--Brian^{Don't try me!} 10:50, 30 April 2014 (EDT)

My point is that there is a pattern of games where the first is good, the second is meh, and the third is better than the first, and stating that I believe SSB4 will follow that pattern. I don't really care for going into more depth than that. Toomai Glittershine The Boss 10:57, 30 April 2014 (EDT)

Doesn't my point still stand? "Better" still and always will be a subjective term. Perhaps you should define the standard we should use here for "good."--Brian^{Don't try me!} 10:59, 30 April 2014 (EDT)

My purpose isn't to address your point; it's to address your foul attitude. DoctorPain99 11:02, 30 April 2014 (EDT)

Take the games I used as examples. The internet at large agrees that they follow the pattern of good-okay-best. Toomai Glittershine The Engineer 11:05, 30 April 2014 (EDT)

While "best" is a subjective term differing between people, one cannot deny forms of media that are critically acclaimed. For all intents and purposes, Brawl is the "best" Smash Bros. as the reviews for the game by many sources are on average above Melee's. More critics, on average, prefer Brawl over Melee. Here are two websites that take the average score of game reviews, and on both sites, Brawl is rated higher. [1] [2] Unknown the Hedgehog 11:12, 30 April 2014 (EDT)

A lot of reviews gave Brawl a perfect score. While I certainly consider it a masterpiece, I can't deny that it has flaws, and doesn't deserve that score. Official game reviews often differ greatly from community opinion. I think Toomai was more accurate; the overall opinion of Brawl is mixed, similarly to Zelda 2 and Castlevania 2 (I wouldn't count SMB 2 because the japanese one didn't "change the formula" like the other examples, although I suppose you'd be right about Doki Doki Panic). ♡FirstaLasto♥ 11:39, 30 April 2014 (EDT)

@DP99: That is a still a rather poor response to my statement. If you really want to change my opinion, present me with facts and reason to do so, not bring up how I offended you.

@Toomai: I get your point. I just want to let you know that because of the rather divided opinions (more melee like vs more brawl like) of what people think is optimal for Smash 4, deciding if Smash 4 is truly the best will be quite hard compared to your examples (none of which are fighting games).

@Unknown The Hedgehog: I am looking at the game from a professional competitor's point of a view, more specifically someone who actually understands the game enough to point out significant flaws. Those game review authors don't actually understand the game at that level. Their reviews mean nothing. Quite frankly, Brawl is a rather shoddy product to make a competitive game out of and given how the Smash fanbase has grown largely thanks to the Smash Documentary on Melee as well as Melee making it to EVO, Smash 4 having more Brawl-esqe features than Melee may hurt it more than help it. Just look at reddit and stream views. Melee is certainly the more dominate and popular smash game this day and age.--Brian^{Don't try me!} 13:39, 30 April 2014 (EDT)

"The third game takes the best of both games and puts them together with new stuff. It's the best of the three."

This. This. This.

It was already stated it's going to be an "inbetween" and all evidence shown so far suggests that it's true. Hell, some stuff seems to be even taken from the mods. Smash 4 is really looking to be the definitive Smash game, and the only people who are shitting on it are the "genwunners" that won't like any new game that makes their first game any less relevant.

I would also point out that the Smash projection here was mirrored pretty well with Pokemon. Gen 1 was pretty much a prototype in the way Smash 64 was, being really bare bones and full of plain bad programming. Gen 2 was a remarked improvement in pretty much every way, mechanics and content wise, and pretty much liked more than Gen 1 universally (except by the really die hard genwunners). Then Gen 3 came, changed things up, and had decidedly mixed reaction. Then Gen 4 came, really improved upon the new stuff Gen 3 did while fixing the mistakes of Gen 3, as well as did some long needed mechanic changes that greatly benefitted the game (i.e. the physical/special split, which for Smash the equivalent looks to be the ledges fix), leading to overall better reaction while ushering in a golden age of competitive play for Pokemon (though of course a lot of genwunners didn't give Gen 4 a chance, like I expect many Melee players to not give Smash 4 a chance).

So yeah, Smash 4 is gonna be pretty amazing. Omega Tyrant 14:43, 30 April 2014 (EDT)