20
edits
Talk:Zelda (SSBB): Difference between revisions
no edit summary
m (Talk:Zelda (SSBB) moved to Talk:Princess Zelda (SSBB) over redirect: Consistency.) |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
Okay, here's my point of contention. When we first got information about Zelda's Twilight Change, it was originally posted in Japanese by someone on 2chan, correct? Some board members did a (machine) translation, and a parenthetical note next to Twilight Change implied that Zelda would transform into a Twilight Princess adaptation of Sheik. This may or may not be true; we have yet to see the front of Zelda's Corocoro card for ourselves (to verify that it is truly listed as such), and the parenthetical note may very well have been a personal addition by the Japanese poster. Until then, we still shouldn't out-and-out confirm Sheik. [[User:Aeris|Aeris]] 11:14, January 11, 2008 (EST) | Okay, here's my point of contention. When we first got information about Zelda's Twilight Change, it was originally posted in Japanese by someone on 2chan, correct? Some board members did a (machine) translation, and a parenthetical note next to Twilight Change implied that Zelda would transform into a Twilight Princess adaptation of Sheik. This may or may not be true; we have yet to see the front of Zelda's Corocoro card for ourselves (to verify that it is truly listed as such), and the parenthetical note may very well have been a personal addition by the Japanese poster. Until then, we still shouldn't out-and-out confirm Sheik. [[User:Aeris|Aeris]] 11:14, January 11, 2008 (EST) | ||
=="Consistency"== | |||
The difference between '''Princess Zelda''' and '''Zelda''' is largely unimportant, but as it is a ''smash'' encyclopedia, it makes more sense to me to have [[Princess Zelda (SSBM)]] redirect to [[Zelda (SSBM)]], as that is how she appears in the game. It's similar to the differences between [[Pikmin & Olimar]] and [[Captain Olimar]]. [[Pikmin & Olimar]] is the gameplay-article and not the redirect because that is how they are presumed to be named for Brawl, even though "Pikmin & Olimar" as a collective single unit was never referenced in previous Pikmin games. Same deal with the [[stages]], which all appear to draw absurd formatting conventions and nomenclature from the stage select screen. If you were going for consistency, moving Zelda to Princess Zelda is the wrong direction. --<font color="000023">'''[[User:Randall00|RJM]]'''</font> <sup>''[[User talk:Randall00|Talk]]''</sup> 12:37, January 19, 2008 (EST) | |||