User talk:Hydreigonfan01

Adding players to the most historically player sections

A quick heads up, if you want to add a player to this section, please bring it up in the talk page first and, if a consensus is reached, the player can be added. Players shouldn’t be added to these sections just because they have a few good results. CookiesCreme 10:21, October 24, 2021 (EDT)

Bump. CookiesCreme 12:14, November 7, 2021 (EST)

Alright then, I'll go do that. I do think Shuton should be added with his recent results as of late using Pyra/Mythra alongside Olimar.--Hydreigonfan01 (talk) 18:44, November 8, 2021 (EST)

Bump, you did it again. Don't add in players without consensus through discussion. NPM Morr!? 10:09, April 2, 2022 (EDT)

Furthermore, outside of weeklies and that one regional, this is the first time KEN used Sephiroth in a tournament, so not only is it too early to know whether KEN would actually stick with the character, but there’s also recency bias, hence why KEN was removed from Sephiroth’s section. If he continues to stick with the character and place well at nationals, I wouldn’t be against to adding him, but we have yet to reach that time. CookiesCreme 10:25, April 2, 2022 (EDT)

Bushido Brawl Impact

While I acknowlege your point about both tournaments having a Top 5 player in attendance (although neither Ally not Mr.R are from USA), there are some important things to note:

1. Bushido Brawl Impact was (and still is) the largest Brawl tournament to happen within an entire continent (Europe), whereas Smash Factor 4 was only the largest within a single country (Mexico) at the time it happened.

2. Less than half of the players who made Top 32 at Bushido Brawl Impact were from France (the region the tournament was held in), meaning tons of players traveled from other countries to compete in it and making it far more international than Smash Factor 4.

3. Even if using the most recent PGRU TTS for Ultimate (which is more lenient to international tournaments than every previous TTS for Smash 4/Ultimate), Smash Factor 4 would at best be only a B-Tier event. While I know Bushido Brawl Impact is technically smaller in size, it should be noted that the scene was much smaller in 2010 than it was in 2015; the largest singles event for any Smash game at the time was 347 for Melee (with Brawl's largest being 303) vs. 1,926 for EVO 2015. PokemonMasterJamal3 (talk) 16:20, March 11, 2022 (EST)

Fair enough I suppose, especially considering back in the Brawl times it's harder to tell what a major is considering there was no PGR, so sure, I'd say Glutonny's win at that event counts.--Hydreigonfan01 (talk) 09:30, March 12, 2022 (EST)

Reminder

You have always seem to forget about the limit of placements on the "Most historically significant players" section. A maximum of 5 offline and 5 online placements are allowed to be listed for each player. This is simply a friendly reminder. NPM Morr!? 00:51, July 3, 2022 (EDT)

Bump, you seem to have forgotten about it again. NPM Morr!? 12:19, August 31, 2022 (EDT)

Wins

For smasher pages, there should be only a maximum of 8 offline and 8 online wins. Anything beyond that is over the limit. So whenever you want to add better wins, make sure it isn't over the limit and if so remove wins that are less good. NPM Morr!? 23:17, August 26, 2022 (EDT)

Gonna remind you about this again, if a player already has eight wins listed, replace the least notable win with whatever win you're adding. Eight is more than enough to get the point across, we don't want intros on smasher articles to become a mass of contextless wins that readers can't comprehend. Omega Tyrant 19:16, June 17, 2023 (EDT)

Yet another reminder of this. Don't just add in players for the sake of adding in wins; remove them as you go if the limit is reached. CookiesCreme 08:58, June 25, 2023 (EDT)

Nair^

While I can't currently check smashdata.gg since it's held together by duct tape, back when I checked last week, SWT: Central America Regional Finals was the only offline set that was listed for Sparg0 and Nair^ post-quarantine. I also checked Liquipedia and PGStats as well. If you're referring to their set at Delfino Maza, that was in 2019; it's not the same event as RETA 2022. PokemonMasterJamal3 (talk) 13:00, April 3, 2023 (EDT)

MHSP summaries

Just a quick heads up, the MHSP guidelines state to actually contextualize why each player is notable rather than list off wins and tournament placements. The Ultimate sections are really bad at this, so I've been slowly going through each section and adding more context instead of just blatantly listing a tournament placement list and win list without context. As such, I removed the win list for ShinyMark's summary since he's the best Pikachu in the post-online metagame and the only other Pikachu player to ever make top 8 at majors, and to be quite honest that basically covers why he is historically significant; a win list doesn't add much else aside from adding bloat to the section. CookiesCreme 21:06, August 30, 2023 (EDT)

VIP categories

While the VIP category pages haven't been updated yet to reflect their pending overhaul and updated guidelines as we are still in the process of formally voting on everyone in these categories, you are not to add any more people into these categories unilaterally, as all future VIP additions will require formal voting. If you wish to propose adding KID or anyone else to these categories, you should join our Discord server and make your case there, as I am building a proposal list for new additions after we clean out the categories, though I'll say now I'm gonna hard veto adding KID to the list as his case is very weak (has not even been globally ranked yet, and just "innovating" a character isn't enough anymore, while it's not like Mii Brawler didn't exist before KID either). Since you do a lot of competitive editing in general and I noticed you've added many players before to the VIP categories, I strongly suggest you join our Discord server anyway to take part in discussions and voting of competitive content on the wiki. Omega Tyrant 15:20, February 26, 2024 (EST)

Since Category:VIP players has been formally updated with the new guidelines and procedures, I thought to prod you once more about it, so you can see what they are before attempting to add or propose anyone in the future. Omega Tyrant 17:04, February 29, 2024 (EST)

Discord

Hey have you ever considered joining the Discord? You seem pretty active on the competitive side of things and we tend to discuss a lot of competitive stuff for the wiki on the Discord. CookiesCreme 17:13, July 25, 2024 (EDT)