Talk:Luigi (SSBM)

Luigi counters fast-fallers? I don't think so... But I don't want this to become a place to argue about match-ups. I think it's better to not mention match-ups in character articles unless it's significant/noteworthy. --Greenblob 01:31, March 14, 2007 (GMT)

Phanna's All Characters Match-Up Chart gives Luigi 4 against Fox and Falco, 2 against Sheik and 3 against Marth. Luigi's best even matches are against the Ice Climbers and Jigglypuff. And Luigi doesn't have any advantageous matches at all, except against the bottom four characters in the game. So according to phanna / some Smashboarders at least, Luigi doesn't counter anybody at all, least of all the space animals. He can survive against them - 4 is a pretty weak disadvantage - but I think it's better to stay away from making hard decisions on controversial matches in the first place. It's clear that Sheik and Marth have strong advantages against Luigi - let's leave it at that. – MaskedMarth ^{(t c)} 16:29, March 14, 2007 (GMT)

No Pros & Cons?

I think that someone should work on giving Luigi all of his pros and cons. Because he's the only Melee character that doesn't have any. What I mean is that he needs to have a section of pros and cons that are listed like the other Melee characters.

It was actually deleted. What you should do is remove them from all the other articles because most are purely subjective and largely unencylcopedic to begin with. The characters are supposed to be balanced--they're not, and we know this, but too many of those lists cite things that are related to the competitive game, when they should apply to anyone who takes an interest. --RJM ^Talk 12:26, January 28, 2008 (EST)

Yeah, I was actually going to bring up the issue of the "Pros & Cons" sections (as well as other sections that seem to be tailored more towards the professional players). I'll go ahead and remove the pros & cons from the other articles. – EP (Talk • Edits) 12:32, January 28, 2008 (EST)