Editing Unity Ruleset Committee

From SmashWiki, the Super Smash Bros. wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
Warning You aren't logged in. While it's not a requirement to create an account, doing so makes it a lot easier to keep track of your edits and a lot harder to confuse you with someone else. If you edit without being logged in, your IP address will be recorded in the page's edit history.

The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.

Latest revision Your text
Line 54: Line 54:
*{{Sm|Mike Haze}}
*{{Sm|Mike Haze}}
*{{Sm|Player-1}}
*{{Sm|Player-1}}
*{{Sm|Ran|p=USA}}
*{{Sm|Ran}}
*{{Sm|The Real Inferno}}
*{{Sm|The Real Inferno}}
*{{Sm|Technical_Chase}}
*{{Sm|Technical_Chase}}
Line 69: Line 69:
==Controversies==
==Controversies==
==={{Sm|Mew2King}} at [[GENESIS 2]]===
==={{Sm|Mew2King}} at [[GENESIS 2]]===
During GENESIS 2's first round of pools, {{Sm|Mew2King}} had swept the rest of his pool with his standard {{SSBB|Meta Knight}}, but against his last opponent, {{Sm|Sade}}, he elected to [[sandbagging|sandbag]] instead by playing {{SSBB|Falco}} and the bottom-tiered {{SSBB|Ganondorf}}, neither of which he ever used previously in serious tournament matches nor been known to seriously practice otherwise. This resulted in M2K losing the set he was expected to easily win, potentially disrupting seeding of the next round of pools and the advancement of other players in the pool, though Sade reported the match as a 2-0 win for M2K to prevent this, feeling the win as undeserved. In response to this apparent [[bracket manipulation]] attempt, the Unity Ruleset Committee gave Mew2King a red card under their infarction system; they officially stated that it was due to having previously received a yellow card for bracket manipulation at [[KTAR 5]], as well as alleging that Mew2King's conduct was sexist in nature, as Sade was a female smasher, and Mew2King's actions implied he did not consider her a serious opponent because of this.  
During GENESIS 2's first round of pools, {{Sm|Mew2King}} had swept the rest of his pool with his standard {{SSBB|Meta Knight}}, but against his last opponent, {{Sm|Sade}}, he elected to [[sandbagging|sandbag]] instead by playing {{SSBB|Falco}} and the bottom-tiered {{SSBB|Ganondorf}}, neither of which he ever used previously in serious tournament matches nor been known to seriously practice otherwise. This resulted in M2K losing the set when he should have easily won 2-0, potentially disrupting seeding of the next round of pools and the advancement of other players in the pool, though Sade reported the match as a 2-0 win for M2K to prevent this, feeling the win as undeserved. In response to this apparent [[bracket manipulation]] attempt, the Unity Ruleset Committee gave Mew2King a red card under their infarction system; they officially stated that it was due to having previously received a yellow card for bracket manipulation at [[KTAR 5]], as well as alleging that Mew2King's conduct was sexist in nature, as Sade was a female smasher, and Mew2King's actions implied he did not consider her a serious opponent because of this.  


The decision to red card Mew2King, however, proved controversial; a number of players believed that as he had already advanced to the next round, Mew2King was allowed one "non-serious" match, particularly if Sade did not voice any complaints about it. And the decision to ban one of the best players from tournaments was controversial in itself, as it was seen from the anti-ban players as diminishing the prestige of any tournament he was not allowed to participate in. Additionally, it was pointed out that the next highest placing player in the pool after Sade, {{Sm|KirinBlaze}}, still didn't make it out of the pool instead of her even with the match being officially recorded as an 0-2 loss for Sade, so it would have had no impact on the advancement of other players, while disrupted seeding wasn't considered a serious concern by those against the ban. Although officially banned from tournaments using the Unity Ruleset until his red card expired, a number of major TOs chose to ignore Mew2King's ban and allowed him to take part in their tournaments if he wanted to; most notably, {{Sm|Keitaro}} and {{Sm|Alex Strife}} refused to recognise the ban and publicly stated that M2K was welcomed to participate at [[KTAR 6]] and [[Apex 2012]] respectively, one of the biggest and the biggest upcoming Brawl tournaments after Genesis 2, undermining the ban and the URC.
The decision to red card Mew2King, however, proved controversial; a number of players believed that as he had already advanced to the next round, Mew2King was allowed one "non-serious" match, particularly if Sade did not voice any complaints about it. And the decision to ban one of the best players from tournaments was controversial in itself, as it was seen from the anti-ban players as diminishing the prestige of any tournament he was not allowed to participate in. Additionally, it was pointed out that the next highest placing player in the pool after Sade, {{Sm|KirinBlaze}}, still didn't make it out of the pool instead of her even with the match being officially recorded as an 0-2 loss for Sade, so it would have had no impact on the advancement of other players, while disrupted seeding wasn't considered a serious concern by those against the ban. Although officially banned from tournaments using the Unity Ruleset until his red card expired, a number of major TOs chose to ignore Mew2King's ban and allowed him to take part in their tournaments if he wanted to; most notably, {{Sm|Keitaro}} and {{Sm|Alex Strife}} refused to recognise the ban and publicly stated that M2K was welcomed to participate at [[KTAR 6]] and [[Apex 2012]] respectively, one of the biggest and the biggest upcoming Brawl tournaments after Genesis 2, undermining the ban and the URC.
Line 76: Line 76:
Amid growing concerns that Meta Knight was proving too dominant a force in ''Brawl'', to the point of centring the [[metagame]] around him, the URC held twice a poll to see whether smashers would be in favour of banning Meta Knight from all ''Brawl'' tournaments or not. The first poll failed, as the "pro-ban" side could not attain a supermajority over the "anti-ban" side; in the second poll, however, "pro-ban" ended up winning with a supermajority of 75%. In response, the URC announced in September of 2011 that Meta Knight would be banned from all ''Brawl'' tournaments, both in singles and doubles, with the ban to start in January 2012.
Amid growing concerns that Meta Knight was proving too dominant a force in ''Brawl'', to the point of centring the [[metagame]] around him, the URC held twice a poll to see whether smashers would be in favour of banning Meta Knight from all ''Brawl'' tournaments or not. The first poll failed, as the "pro-ban" side could not attain a supermajority over the "anti-ban" side; in the second poll, however, "pro-ban" ended up winning with a supermajority of 75%. In response, the URC announced in September of 2011 that Meta Knight would be banned from all ''Brawl'' tournaments, both in singles and doubles, with the ban to start in January 2012.


Despite the widespread support for the ban, a number of top players stated that they would not support the Meta Knight ban, and that they would not attend any tournaments that used the URC's ruleset; in response, a number of major TOs chose to use their own rulesets instead of the URC's ruleset, as to encourage top players to not only enter their tournaments, but to increase the number of potential viewers on their streams and videos. Most significantly, {{Sm|Alex Strife}} refused to ban Meta Knight for [[Apex]], the biggest ''Brawl'' tournament series. A number of regions, however, continued to recognise the ban, leading to a fractured community where stage lists were different between regions owing to different legalities on Meta Knight; this was due to the fact that some stages strongly favoured Meta Knight's oppressive aerial, [[camping]], and [[shark]]ing game, such as [[Brinstar]] and [[Halberd]]. Furthermore, several players refused to travel to other regions, depending on whether or not Meta Knight was banned. These regions that kept Meta Knight banned however would eventually relegalize him, so that their region's players wouldn't lack crucial matchup experience against him and thus be ill-prepared for the major tournaments that kept him legal. Within a year of the URC putting the Meta Knight ban into action, Meta Knight being legal became the universal standard again, with few tournaments banning him after that point.
Despite the widespread support for the ban, a number of top professionals stated that they would not recognise the Meta Knight ban, and that they would not attend any tournaments that used the URC; in response, a number of major TOs chose to use their own rulesets instead of the URC's ruleset, as to encourage top players to not only enter their tournaments, but to increase the number of potential viewers on their streams and videos. Most significantly, {{Sm|Alex Strife}} refused to ban Meta Knight for [[Apex]], the biggest Brawl tournament series. A number of regions, however, continued to recognise the ban, leading to a fractured community where stage lists were different between regions owing to different legalities on Meta Knight; this was due to the fact that some stages strongly favoured Meta Knight's oppressive aerial, [[camping]], and [[shark]]ing game, such as [[Brinstar]] and [[Halberd]]. Furthermore, several players refused to travel to other regions, depending on whether or not Meta Knight was banned. These regions that kept Meta Knight banned however would eventually relegalize him, so that their region's players wouldn't lack crucial matchup experience against him and thus be ill-prepared for the major tournaments that kept him legal. Within a year of the URC putting the Meta Knight ban into action, Meta Knight being legal became the universal standard again, with few tournaments banning him after that point.


The resultant fracture of the ''Brawl'' tournament scene following the ban on Meta Knight is seen as a tipping point for the URC, as its attempt to create a unified tournament scene had failed. The URC later disbanded in April 2012 in response to having lost favor of the community.
The resultant fracture of the ''Brawl'' tournament scene following the ban on Meta Knight is seen as a tipping point for the URC, as its attempt to create a unified tournament scene had failed. The URC later disbanded in April 2012 in response to having lost favour of the community.


[[Category:Competitive play]]
[[Category:Competitive play]]

Please note that all contributions to SmashWiki are considered to be released under the Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported license (see SmashWiki:Copyrights for details). Your changes will be visible immediately. Please enter a summary of your changes above.

Do not submit copyrighted work without permission!

Cancel Editing help (opens in new window)

Templates used on this page: