Talk:RetroSSBMRank

If the 'Honorable Mentions' are listed in a descending order from most to least notable, there were only two majors for the year 2008, one of them being won by Amsah. He is listed -below- the 2nd and 3rd place finishers of that tournament, Captain Jack and Armada. This seems like an error, not to mention the fact that winning one of the two majors for that year failed to lead him to be ranked at all. 135.23.41.56 23:35, March 11, 2026 (UTC)

I don't think the honorable mentions were ever meant to have a proper order. I assume Amsah was excluded because there wasn't enough known tournament data, especially his sets against Americans, for him to be properly ranked; that was at least the case for most international honorable mentions. That, and Edwin himself has since said it's best to treat the rankings as a "broad" idea of what the scene was like back then rather than a definitive ranking. CookiesCreme 01:56, March 12, 2026 (UTC)