Tournament:Supernova 2024: Difference between revisions

m
→‎Disqualification controversy: merged a few paragraphs together since it felt weird reading them separately and a few small wording adjustments
m (→‎Disqualification controversy: merged a few paragraphs together since it felt weird reading them separately and a few small wording adjustments)
Line 58: Line 58:


===Disqualification controversy===
===Disqualification controversy===
During the ''Smash 4'' events, {{Sm|VaLoR}} chose to replace {{Sm|RiskTKR}} in the singles event as RiskTKR had planned on DQing while VaLoR forgot to sign up. In addition, {{Sm|Ouch!?}} switched with VaLoR and teamed with {{Sm|TemporaryPlan}} in the doubles event. Despite getting permission to do all of this from the bracket manager and some of the tournament organizers (this point is under contention), all of the aforementioned players except TemporaryPlan were ultimately disqualified from the entire Supernova event by a different tournament organizer for bracket manipulation.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://x.com/RiskTKR3/status/1822376075978310099|title=RiskTKR on his disqualification}}</ref> TemporaryPlan had just been eliminated from bracket by {{Sm|BroKen}} when the disqualifications had begun.
During the ''Smash 4'' events, {{Sm|VaLoR}} chose to replace {{Sm|RiskTKR}} in the singles event as RiskTKR had planned on DQing while VaLoR forgot to sign up. In addition, {{Sm|Ouch!?}} switched with VaLoR and teamed with {{Sm|TemporaryPlan}} in the doubles event. Despite allegedly receiving permission to do all of this from the bracket manager and some of the tournament organizers, all of the aforementioned players except TemporaryPlan were ultimately disqualified from the entire Supernova event by a different tournament organizer for bracket manipulation.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://x.com/RiskTKR3/status/1822376075978310099|title=RiskTKR on his disqualification}}</ref> This disqualification affected the ''Ultimate'' bracket, as both RiskTKR and Ouch!? were still in the winner's side of bracket prior to their disqualification, with Ouch!? especially being in the top 128. Conversely, TemporaryPlan was not disqualified as he was eliminated from bracket by {{Sm|BroKen}} before the disqualifications.  


This disqualification affected the ''Ultimate'' bracket, as both RiskTKR and Ouch!? were still in the winner's side of bracket prior to their disqualification, with Ouch!? especially being in the top 128. RiskTKR later identified said tournament organizer as {{Sm|Roflfox}} and alleged that Roflfox did not make the decision with the head organizer of Supernova.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://x.com/RiskTKR3/status/1822392160106246148|title=RiskTKR's update}}</ref> This claim was corroborated in a now-deleted Tweet from Roflfox, where he disqualified three players on the basis of Rule 3.15, which discussed "alting".<ref>{{cite web|url=https://x.com/PhoenixSSBM/status/1822395164746203217|title=Deleted Tweet from Roflfox}}</ref>  
RiskTKR later identified said tournament organizer as {{Sm|Roflfox}} and alleged that Roflfox did not make the decision with the head organizer of Supernova.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://x.com/RiskTKR3/status/1822392160106246148|title=RiskTKR's update}}</ref> This claim was corroborated in a now-deleted Tweet from Roflfox, where he disqualified three players on the basis of Rule 3.15, which discussed "alting".<ref>{{cite web|url=https://x.com/PhoenixSSBM/status/1822395164746203217|title=Deleted Tweet from Roflfox}}</ref> Roflfox later responded, saying that he and two other organizers did not approve any swaps at any point during the weekend, and that the pool captains would not have been allowed to do so.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://x.com/adam_ssbu/status/1822384173685805335|title=Roflfox's response}}</ref> Nevertheless, the incident and Roflfox's deleted Tweet drew were criticized online, especially from the [[Utah]] community, with many also questioning why all four players were disqualified from their other non-''Smash 4'' events despite the incident taking place in ''Smash 4''.  
 
Roflfox later responded to the controversy, saying that he and two other organizers did not approve any swaps at any point during the weekend, and that the pool captains would not have been allowed to do so.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://x.com/adam_ssbu/status/1822384173685805335|title=Roflfox's response}}</ref> Nevertheless, the incident and Roflfox's deleted Tweet drew were criticized online, especially from the [[Utah]] community, with many also questioning why all four players were disqualified from their other non-''Smash 4'' events despite the incident taking place in ''Smash 4''.  


RiskTKR ultimately received a refund on his registration, partial funding for his travels, and free entry to {{Trn|Luminosity Makes Moves 2024}}, however it is unknown whether the other three players received any compensation. In addition, Roflfox later apologized for his deleted Tweets and how the situation was handled, but stood by his decision.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://x.com/TheRoflfox/status/1822839348007424173|title=Roflfox's later response}}</ref>
RiskTKR ultimately received a refund on his registration, partial funding for his travels, and free entry to {{Trn|Luminosity Makes Moves 2024}}, however it is unknown whether the other three players received any compensation. In addition, Roflfox later apologized for his deleted Tweets and how the situation was handled, but stood by his decision.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://x.com/TheRoflfox/status/1822839348007424173|title=Roflfox's later response}}</ref>


After the convention ended, Roflfox addressed and explained in detail the timeline of the events of the weekend<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bbyFbia6izo|title=Roflfox on the events that happened at Supernova}}</ref> , including the alleged claims that the players had permission to make the swaps.
After the convention ended, Roflfox addressed and explained in detail the timeline of the events of the weekend,<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bbyFbia6izo|title=Roflfox on the events that happened at Supernova}}</ref> including the alleged claims that the players had permission to make the swaps.


==Results==
==Results==