I'm highly doubtful that anyone will find this page, but if you do, hi! I consider myself an "inbetweener" in the smash community, my skill levels are higher than the average player, but are mediocre at best in a competitive setting. In Melee I am a Peach main primarily, but I use Zelda/Sheik as well. In Brawl I'm much the same, Peach main primarily but I also use Zelda/Sheik, as for SSB4, I have many mains and secondary's, they are as follows in order of how much use age they see and how proficient I am with them.
1. Rosalina & Luma. 2. Peach. 3. Zelda. 4. Lucina 5. Zero suit Samus. 6. Robin 7. Wii Fit Trainer 8. Palutena ( very rarely )
My personal tier list for Melee
S Always very viable
1. Fox
2. Falco
3. Shiek
4. Marth
5. Peach
6. Jigglypuff
A Viable
7. Falcon
8. Samus
9. Luigi
10. Ganondorf
11. Pikachu
12. Zelda/ Shiek
A- Viable/semi viable
13. Yoshi ( AMSA )
14. Dr. Mario
15. Mario
16. Zelda
17. Young Link
B+ Semi / non viable
18. Link
19. Ice climbers ( rusults are too inconsistent to keep them in the top tier and everyone knows how to fight them at this point, just kill nana )
20. Roy
21. DK
B- Usually non viable without secondary's
22. GA
C zero chance in a national
23. Pichu
24. Ness
25. Bowser
C- Utter Shit
26. Mewtwo
27. Kirby