|
NOTE: Put all new talk page posts on the bottom of the page. Thank you :) |
| The Archives | |
|---|---|
| Archive 1 | Archive 2 |
| Archive 3 | Archive 4 |
Bocchi
Do you think you could help me with the Bocchi article? the links in the controversy section broke for some reason.ClemSSB (talk) 06:08, March 2, 2022 (EST)
Oh. I wouldn’t have made another one if I realised she didn’t want one. I was wondering why she didn’t have one already lolClemSSB (talk) 06:53, March 2, 2022 (EST)
Browi
Hi I'm really new to this. I emailed you through the "email this user" option. Please take a look. Thank you! —Preceding unsigned comment added by Browi (talk • contribs) 23:24, May 10, 2022
- In the future, you can contact me right here on my talk page. It's much more faster than the "email this user" option.
- Regards to your first question, if an edit conflict takes place, you can scroll all the way down and see the edits that you were going to make. All you need to do is copy and paste the changes you want to make back into the main article. If you got any other questions, you can just let me know. Cookies
Creme 23:27, May 10, 2022 (EDT)
Thank you. Do you have any information on how to make pages? I'd like to create some pages for the smashers in my scene. —Preceding unsigned comment added by Browi (talk • contribs) 23:39, May 10, 2022 (EDT)
- In order to have access to page creation, you need to be autoconfirmed (7 days after your first edit, 10 edits). Before making a Smasher page, I recommend taking a look at SW:SMASHER and SW:NOTABLE for guidelines on who can get a page, as well as how to create a page. It's also helpful to copy what an existing Smasher page already has. Cookies Creme 23:41, May 10, 2022 (EDT)
Apology
I’m sorry for spam-like edits I made on SmashWiki. I promise you that I’m not a vandal. 174.55.24.64 16:54, June 6, 2022 (EDT)
- You're missing the point. It's not about whether you're spamming or a vandal. The points you have been making have constantly been redundant or irrelevant, and from what I can tell it's because you're enthusiastic about adding anything that you discover, even if it has no reason being there. I'm telling you to take a step back and consider whether something is necessary and correct before adding it. Cookies Creme 21:46, June 6, 2022 (EDT)
This edit summary
I believe what that edit was trying to say is that Isabelle is the first fighter whose playable debut in any capacity is a game that's not her own series (that being Mario Kart 8 DLC in early 2015).
Admittedly, I'm too strapped for time to check and see if a fighter released/revealed before her also had this distinction, but I can certainly say she's not the only one to have it, as like you said, Banjo first appeared as a playable racer in Diddy Kong Racing. 
The Jacketed Terrapin
03:36, January 30, 2023 (EST)
- I mean, there is a large handful of characters that made their playable debut in Smash, which isn't their own series, so I think the point is moot regardless, if you as me. Aidan the Celebratory Gamer 12:32, January 30, 2023 (EST)
- Even then, that feels like trivia for an Animal Crossing wiki than this wiki, since it has nothing to do with Isabelle in Smash. Cookies Creme 12:48, January 30, 2023 (EST)
Removing picture
Hi!
I was going through my smash wiki and saw a picture you uploaded a few years ago (thank you for your work btw!!!). For personal reasons I would like to have it removed. If you could contact me on Twitter for the link to the picture and maybe to know my reasons, it would be much appreciated. Here's my twitter handle : @Dia2B.
Thanks a lot in advance!
Dia2B (talk) 20:42, February 22, 2023 (EST)
- I don't have the power to delete the picture from the wiki, but I've sent the info to the admins; they'll take care of it and may be the ones contacting you. Cookies Creme 21:14, February 22, 2023 (EST)
- I tried sending you a DM to verify, but I keep getting a "message failed to send" error, you can try sending me a DM, or just @me if you can't either to verify this is you. After verification, the picture can be deleted without any additional reason provided, I'll just need to know if it's only that specific picture you don't want up or if you don't want any pictures of yourself on the wiki. Omega Tyrant
21:22, February 22, 2023 (EST)
Best Pikachu
Hello, I do not know much about editing, so I am very sorry if I am doing something wrong talking to you here, but I think you are right with your edit, although I think it would be better to say on the second part something like this "However, ShinyMark has recently shown in tournament play that he has had severe improvement over the past few months, and although ESAM is the best Pikachu play in Super Smash Bros Ultimate overall, that may change soon with time. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 152.157.183.189 (talk • contribs) 20:38, May 27, 2023
- First, I responded to your talk page post, so I won't be repeating how to properly post a talk page post.
- Second, in my opinion your sentence is wordier and is only implying that ESAM may not be the uncontested best Pikachu right now, and as I've explained on ESAM's talk page, it's pretty clear that ShinyMark's results are on-par if not significantly better than what ESAM has in the same period. Cookies Creme 20:48, May 27, 2023 (EDT)
Adding a Tournament summary section to all new tournament articles
Hey there,
So basically my current complaint about a lot of the tournament articles is that the Trivia sections tend to get excessively long, and filled with stuff that should be written somewhere else in the article. For example, for GENESIS 8 and GENESIS 9 over half the trivia points should really be in their own section. My proposed solution is to make sure every tournament has a summary section where people can put significant info about the events that happened during the tournament. I did this for a lot of Melee tournaments when I was more active here but would like to keep it going as a standard if possible. I don't think this is anyone's fault in particular (because it's easier to add bullet points to Trivia instead of creating a new section entirely) but I think this would help keep things more organized overall.
In my ideal world every tournament article would look like EVO 2013, Apex 2015, or Get On My Level 2016, where the page has a summary of the main events that happened, and the Trivia is short and limited to interesting facts/coincidences, like Taylor Hicks at EVO 2013, instead of significant events relating to the bracket. (I added the Melee summary for GOML right after the tournament ended, and then someone else added the Smash 4 info later, so as long as a section is available I think people will catch on).
As such, would you be down to help me by creating a "Tournament summary" section for every new tournament (at least for majors)? I see that you've created a lot of the new tournament articles so I figured I'd ask you about it first. Awesome Cardinal 2000 13:54, June 3, 2023 (EDT)
- I'm fine with it. In the past I had gripes with trivia in tournament pages that feel like they should belong in their own section, so I've been trying to write sections similar to tournament summary sections that you've mentioned, or at least have a summary of the tournament in the introduction (eg, Maesuma TOP 12 and Kagaribi 10). I do think it's a case-by-case situation though, since there are majors which seem to be relatively "normal"/don't have much to cover that couldn't be covered elsewhere, and for the most part anything below the level of major is also rather uneventful, but nevertheless I think a tournament summary section is certainly warranted especially for supermajors like Battle of BC. Cookies Creme 14:06, June 3, 2023 (EDT)
- Great, thanks for you help Awesome Cardinal 2000 16:02, June 3, 2023 (EDT)
Two Things
Number one, I am sorry for inserting unnecessary trivia into Zero Suit Samus' article. Number two, how is the coincidental similarity between Zero Suit Samus and Yang Xiao Long (from RWBY) irrelevant to Smash or Zero Suit Samus' design? 86.18.61.190 09:26, June 23, 2023 (EDT)
- Read SW:TRIVIA and SW:1RV, insert your shitty "trivia" again and you will be blocked. Omega Tyrant 09:38, June 23, 2023 (EDT)
- First, "in a way" implies speculation, which we don't allow on the wiki.
- Second, aside from looking similar and having similar skillsets, what does Zero Suit Samus have to do with Yang? They're two completely different characters from two completely different franchises, so not only is your trivia point literally doing nothing but comparing two characters of no relation, but you could also make the same point with any blonde-hair fighter in any media (and there are a ton of that, such as characters from this list I just pulled up), which instantly makes the trivia point moot and irrelevant.
- Third, even if it's confirmed that Yang took her design from Zero Suit Samus, it has absolutely nothing to do with how Zero Suit Samus looks in Smash, nor does it even affect how Zero Suit Samus is designed. Rather, it's more so information that belongs on a RWBY wiki since it's talking about Yang's design, and Yang is a character that has no relation to Smash at all.. Cookies Creme 09:44, June 23, 2023 (EDT)
Recent tournaments
Hello, where did you find lists of recent tournaments like ones shown on UltRank 2023 article? StartGG won't show every other Smash tournaments that are either B+ or below. (i.e. Most non-US tournaments) CSR (talk) 13:24, July 17, 2023 (EDT)
- I usually just use the UltRank TTS for Ultimate tournaments -- which lists most of the relevant Ultimate tournaments -- and MeleeStats's When's Melee articles for Melee. There is also Smash Calendar but I don't really use it. I do still use Start.gg's tournament search from time-to-time especially for reference but I often find it unreliable and glitchy. Cookies Creme 13:32, July 17, 2023 (EDT)
Thanks for all the tournament results updates
Hey, I noticed that the smashers' tournament results are often up to date within hours of results coming out. It's honestly impressive and goes a great ways to keep the wiki relevant. Thank you for the work you do. Lasercatte (talk) 21:40, October 25, 2023 (EDT)
Ness (SSBU)
Hey there! It seems we have some differences on how to approach the Ness article, particularly with regard to his competitive positioning. It's better we hash those out here than get into an editing war. Just a few points I would like to make:
- Ness hasn't seen a large decline in results over time. He is still well-represented in tournaments.
- Gackt has become more consistent recently, with a strong showing at Genesis to back it up.
- Sonic is not a bad matchup for Ness. In fact, Ness is one of few characters to consistently give Sonix trouble. FOW, Gackt, and Scend have all taken sets from him.
- I think it's important to provide context for LumiRank's tier list. It's only one tier list, and it was heavily criticized by top players on social media.