Talk:Zelda (SSBB): Difference between revisions
m (Talk:Zelda (SSBB) moved to Talk:Princess Zelda (SSBB) over redirect: Consistency.) |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
Okay, here's my point of contention. When we first got information about Zelda's Twilight Change, it was originally posted in Japanese by someone on 2chan, correct? Some board members did a (machine) translation, and a parenthetical note next to Twilight Change implied that Zelda would transform into a Twilight Princess adaptation of Sheik. This may or may not be true; we have yet to see the front of Zelda's Corocoro card for ourselves (to verify that it is truly listed as such), and the parenthetical note may very well have been a personal addition by the Japanese poster. Until then, we still shouldn't out-and-out confirm Sheik. [[User:Aeris|Aeris]] 11:14, January 11, 2008 (EST) | Okay, here's my point of contention. When we first got information about Zelda's Twilight Change, it was originally posted in Japanese by someone on 2chan, correct? Some board members did a (machine) translation, and a parenthetical note next to Twilight Change implied that Zelda would transform into a Twilight Princess adaptation of Sheik. This may or may not be true; we have yet to see the front of Zelda's Corocoro card for ourselves (to verify that it is truly listed as such), and the parenthetical note may very well have been a personal addition by the Japanese poster. Until then, we still shouldn't out-and-out confirm Sheik. [[User:Aeris|Aeris]] 11:14, January 11, 2008 (EST) | ||
=="Consistency"== | |||
The difference between '''Princess Zelda''' and '''Zelda''' is largely unimportant, but as it is a ''smash'' encyclopedia, it makes more sense to me to have [[Princess Zelda (SSBM)]] redirect to [[Zelda (SSBM)]], as that is how she appears in the game. It's similar to the differences between [[Pikmin & Olimar]] and [[Captain Olimar]]. [[Pikmin & Olimar]] is the gameplay-article and not the redirect because that is how they are presumed to be named for Brawl, even though "Pikmin & Olimar" as a collective single unit was never referenced in previous Pikmin games. Same deal with the [[stages]], which all appear to draw absurd formatting conventions and nomenclature from the stage select screen. If you were going for consistency, moving Zelda to Princess Zelda is the wrong direction. --<font color="000023">'''[[User:Randall00|RJM]]'''</font> <sup>''[[User talk:Randall00|Talk]]''</sup> 12:37, January 19, 2008 (EST) | |||
Revision as of 12:37, January 19, 2008
how the second edit about her role in the story mode considered vandalism?
^^^ I don't know. But people, stop changing Zelda's B move to Nayru's Love. It hasn't been confirmed! Ethanrodgers223 10:30, November 8, 2007 (EST)
i thought you could only choose between mario and kirby in the beginning?
Twilight Change
Okay, here's my point of contention. When we first got information about Zelda's Twilight Change, it was originally posted in Japanese by someone on 2chan, correct? Some board members did a (machine) translation, and a parenthetical note next to Twilight Change implied that Zelda would transform into a Twilight Princess adaptation of Sheik. This may or may not be true; we have yet to see the front of Zelda's Corocoro card for ourselves (to verify that it is truly listed as such), and the parenthetical note may very well have been a personal addition by the Japanese poster. Until then, we still shouldn't out-and-out confirm Sheik. Aeris 11:14, January 11, 2008 (EST)
"Consistency"
The difference between Princess Zelda and Zelda is largely unimportant, but as it is a smash encyclopedia, it makes more sense to me to have Princess Zelda (SSBM) redirect to Zelda (SSBM), as that is how she appears in the game. It's similar to the differences between Pikmin & Olimar and Captain Olimar. Pikmin & Olimar is the gameplay-article and not the redirect because that is how they are presumed to be named for Brawl, even though "Pikmin & Olimar" as a collective single unit was never referenced in previous Pikmin games. Same deal with the stages, which all appear to draw absurd formatting conventions and nomenclature from the stage select screen. If you were going for consistency, moving Zelda to Princess Zelda is the wrong direction. --RJM Talk 12:37, January 19, 2008 (EST)
