1,520
edits
Talk:Sheik/Archive 1: Difference between revisions
→Profile image
SeanWheeler (talk | contribs) |
|||
| Line 102: | Line 102: | ||
::"''These articles aren't covering their Smash appearances, this covers their appearances in their own series''" why?<br><br>Why should we need to cover characters changes and histories in their own games, when we have links to their character articles dedicated too them in their own games on their smash pages. The SSB Wiki should only have to have the bare essentials, such as personality, and basic run down of their abilities. If those browsing the wiki really want to learn more about these characters histories, character relations, and see other art works of them, all they have to do is simply click the links provided. This is a Smash Bros. wiki, not a Nintendo Gaming Library Wiki.<br>[[User:Ixbran|Ixbran]] ([[User talk:Ixbran|talk]]) 18:50, 13 June 2014 (EDT) | ::"''These articles aren't covering their Smash appearances, this covers their appearances in their own series''" why?<br><br>Why should we need to cover characters changes and histories in their own games, when we have links to their character articles dedicated too them in their own games on their smash pages. The SSB Wiki should only have to have the bare essentials, such as personality, and basic run down of their abilities. If those browsing the wiki really want to learn more about these characters histories, character relations, and see other art works of them, all they have to do is simply click the links provided. This is a Smash Bros. wiki, not a Nintendo Gaming Library Wiki.<br>[[User:Ixbran|Ixbran]] ([[User talk:Ixbran|talk]]) 18:50, 13 June 2014 (EDT) | ||
:::These articles are only summaries of the character in their series. And the articles are relevant since Sheik is in Smash, and since she's in Smash it makes sense to have an article that is about her canon appearance in the Zelda games (not in depth like Zelda Wiki, but a brief summary of the character). And since this is about her appearance in the Zelda games and not Smash, as Red and I have stated, the image should reflect the game(s) she's actually appeared in regardless of conceptual designs. [[User:Unknown the Hedgehog|<font color="#FF0000">Unknown </font>]] [[User talk:Unknown the Hedgehog|<font color="#780000">the </font>]] [[Special:Contributions/Unknown the Hedgehog|<font color="#000000">Hedgehog</font>]] 20:23, 13 June 2014 (EDT) | :::These articles are only summaries of the character in their series. And the articles are relevant since Sheik is in Smash, and since she's in Smash it makes sense to have an article that is about her canon appearance in the Zelda games (not in depth like Zelda Wiki, but a brief summary of the character). And since this is about her appearance in the Zelda games and not Smash, as Red and I have stated, the image should reflect the game(s) she's actually appeared in regardless of conceptual designs. [[User:Unknown the Hedgehog|<font color="#FF0000">Unknown </font>]] [[User talk:Unknown the Hedgehog|<font color="#780000">the </font>]] [[Special:Contributions/Unknown the Hedgehog|<font color="#000000">Hedgehog</font>]] 20:23, 13 June 2014 (EDT) | ||
::::Actually, these articles are not summaries of the characters in their series. They are summaries of the fighters in the Smash series as a whole. You don't read about Sheik's role in Ocarana of Time. You see sections about Melee, Brawl and SSB4. Pages like Sheik (SSBB) are subpages that have more detailed info and data about the playable fighter in that game. If it was about Sheik's role in Ocarana of Time, it wouldn't belong here. You can find that page at Zelda Wiki. Anyway, I think I might have something to do with it. I did you guys to replace the Villager picture that show his artwork from New Leaf with the one from City Folk that resembles more like his Smash appearance. I think because of that change, we got this problem. There seems to be a reason why we use the artwork from their series. It's not because it's an article about the character as he/she appears in his/her own series, but so that they don't share the same profile pic as their recent fighter subpage. And I do think that each general character page should use the artwork that's the closest to Smash. However, in my opinion, concept artwork of a an appearance that didn't happen isn't a great choice of profile pic. Sure, the OoT pic is missing a few bandages, and Sakurai based her appearance on concept art. But I prefer the Oot artwork. I'm on Ixbran's side about having the artwork of characters closer to their Smash design, but I'm also on Chuck's side of not using concept artwork of a cancelled appearance. [[User:SeanWheeler|SeanWheeler]] ([[User talk:SeanWheeler|talk]]) 23:42, 13 June 2014 (EDT) | |||