Talk:Peach (SSB4): Difference between revisions

m
→‎Changes From Brawl Section: I read everything you said, so please don't assume I just reverted you blindly. I'll apologize for fully reverting your edit, though.
No edit summary
m (→‎Changes From Brawl Section: I read everything you said, so please don't assume I just reverted you blindly. I'll apologize for fully reverting your edit, though.)
Line 89: Line 89:
But what REALLY bothers is me is that rather then keep some of the new details I added (like the buffs Peach received), you just reverted it. Which makes me strongly believe that you didn't really read it to begin with.
But what REALLY bothers is me is that rather then keep some of the new details I added (like the buffs Peach received), you just reverted it. Which makes me strongly believe that you didn't really read it to begin with.
[[User:Nightgengale|Nightgengale]] ([[User talk:Nightgengale|talk]]) 21:38, 12 February 2017 (EST)
[[User:Nightgengale|Nightgengale]] ([[User talk:Nightgengale|talk]]) 21:38, 12 February 2017 (EST)
:"Peach's top level results have been lackluster since the Umeki Rainbow nerf."
:This is untrue. Peach's results have actually been fine even with the nerf you're describing. Samsora has placed Top 8 at a few nationals (namely 2nd at Clutch City Clash, double eliminating Ally, as well as 7th at KTAR XIX) and Top 32 at The Big House 6, and has been performing very well at regionals as well. Kie also ended up placing Top 32 at The Big House 6, taking out players like Rich Brown. Ling Ling placed 13th at Shine 2016, taking out players such as Anti. Furthermore, both Kie and Umeki have placed Top 8 at multiple stacked Japanese tournaments since then, with Umeki notably placing 5th at SGC 2017. I think you would be hard pressed to say that Peach's results were better in Brawl even despite this nerf. Hell, her pre-patch results weren't this good, even.
:"Peach has been buffed as a character, but the new mechanic changes (Edge Trumping, Rage, Phantom Footstooling, Untechable Reeling Animation etc.) combined with the direct nerfs Peach got end up making Peach less viable overall."
:She's not less viable, though. Her results are '''better''' than they ever were in Brawl. This is the exact problem I have with what you wrote.
:"But what REALLY bothers is me is that rather then keep some of the new details I added (like the buffs Peach received), you just reverted it. Which makes me strongly believe that you didn't really read it to begin with."
:I did read everything you wrote, so please don't assume otherwise; I just didn't know exactly how to re-phrase particular parts of it. Yes, I probably shouldn't have removed everything, so I'll apologize for that, but I also wasn't going to let the whole "Peach is less viable" part stand either. [[User:PokemonMasterJamal3|PokemonMasterJamal3]] ([[User talk:PokemonMasterJamal3|talk]]) 22:05, 12 February 2017 (EST)